Housing Forums (public)


Energy Forums (members only)

Log-in to post and see information on new planning applications, dates of planning meetings and much more.
Note that registration on the Energy Forums is only activated to those on the Protect Devon e-mail database. If you are not known to us, please ask an existing member to propose your membership to the board administator.
Registration requires confirmation and it may take up to 24 hours for this to be verified.
If you have any difficulty in registering, please contact the board administrator


Rogues Gallery


Contact us


News
More news items are available to members

24/10/2014
In April 2014, Taw Turbine Action Group made a complaint to the Advertising Standards Authority about the claims made by RES UK & Ireland Ltd's claims for the output of the Den Brook Wind Farm. Both complaints were upheld and adjudication can be found here

News Archive
(was "From the Papers")

Protect Devon was formed as an alliance supporting the protection of rural Devon from the introduction of inappropriately sited energy schemes.  These include renewable energy schemes such as wind turbines, solar power stations, anaerobic digesters and more recently battery storage schemes and banks of diesel generators.

Since 2015, the Government has made drastic reductions in subsidies to smaller renewable energy developments via the Feed-in-Tariff (FiT) scheme and has closed the Renewables Obligation (RO) scheme for larger developments.  The Written Ministerial Statement of 18th June 2015 and the subsequent changes made to the Planning Practice Guidance have ended the mass of planning applications from the so-called renewables industry for wind turbines and resulted in nearly all applications being refused, whilst most of those appealed have been dismissed by the Planning Inspectorate.  This corresponds with current government policy to put an end to onshore wind farms, which includes individual wind turbines.

The main concerns on the energy front now consist of ongoing noise problems from wind turbines; ongoing pollution and human health issues from anaerobic digesters including the spreading of digestate; and applications for battery storage schemes and banks of diesel generators.

However, the major concern across the whole of Devon is now housing.  Government policy is now focused on housing "need" and forcing local authorities to allot large areas of greenfield land for housing development.  This can be seen in all new Local Plans and concepts like the Greater Exeter Strategic Plan (GESP) which will affect Exeter, East Devon, Mid Devon and Teignbridge.  The need for affordable housing in rural communities gets ignored.  We are therefore introducing a new forum devoted to information concerning housing developments.  All existing members will be able to access the new section.  New members will not be able to access the existing energy forum except following vetting.

If you would like to help protect Devon and join our alliance, please contact us.

This site is sponsored by CPRE Devon, the only environmental charity which actively campaigns for the Devon countryside and for rural communities.  We encourage all our members to join CPRE Devon and fight for our countryside. 

Too Much Slurry is a Devon-based campaign which is concerned about mega farming, slurry and digestate.  If you have any concerns about digestate, and slurry from mega dairies please also register with Too much Slurry.  [link to Too much Slurry]


Update 26th November 2016
Dr Phillip Bratby has now concluded his report The Disastrous Impact of Renewable Energy in Devon. The review covers the development of renewable energy in Devon over the last 13 years. It is based upon the information given in the annual reports
produced by RegenSW, the leading promoter of renewable energy in the South West.
The review also looks at renewable energy in Cornwall and the South West, but
providing less detail. Over 80% of renewable energy capacity is in the form of
electricity generation, so the review has predominantly focussed on renewable
electricity. To download the full report, please click here.

Update 21st May 2016
Following meetings of both Torridge and North Devon's Full Councils, the Local Plan is now moving forward for inspection with the renewable energy part excluding wind energy developments as per 6.19A in its shortened form. This reflects government policy as outlined in the 18th June 2015 Written Ministerial Statement and means that the whole of northern Devon is now closed to onshore wind energy devolopment.

Update 18 April 2016
At today's meeting of Torridge District Council's Community & Resources Committee, the overwhelming response opposing the proposals in the second consultation to reject the proposed policy DM11B was heeded with the adoption of the alternative 6.19A "In accordance with Government Guidance, proposals for wind energy development will only be permitted where they are in an area identified as suitable for wind energy development which is allocated in a Neighbourhood Plan or a Development Plan Document. The District Councils will regularly review the need to amend this Local Plan or produce a subsequent Development Plan Document to address the requirement for such development". There was considerable community support for an amendment proposed by Cllr Brenton to end this Minor Modification to the Local Plan at the words "Neighbourhood Plan." This was however defeated on a vote, 3 in favour, 4 against and 2 abstentions. The complete Minor Modification was passed on a vote of 6 for, 2 against and one abstention.

This now goes forward to North Devon Council Executive Committee on 3rd May for their deliberations.

Update 2 February 2016
A recent threat has been a consultation initiated by North Devon and Torridge District Councils to identify "areas suitable for wind energy development" with four options under consideration. None of these options allow for the Local Plans to be based on the status quo which is that there are no areas designated as suitable for wind energy development. Despite the fact that the vast majority of those who replied to the consultation don't want any areas adopted as suitable for wind energy development, both councils have adopted consultation's Option 1. This covers the whole of the two districts, including the protected Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty, Exmoor National Park and, believe it or not, Lundy.

Map X

Protect Devon is concerned that if North Devon and Torridge's Local Plan includes a map showing the whole area to be suitable for wind energy development, then not only could there be a rash of applications, but the area could be very vulnerable to future changes of policy with regard to wind power. It would also set a precedent which other parts of Devon could follow.

Needless to say, Protect Devon are opposed to these proposal and are actively lobbying for the adoption of the missing "Option 5", that is for no areas of Torridge and North Devon to be designated as suitable for wind energy development – simply because they are not suitable.

The consultation is about to enter its second stage and Protect Devon, and its supporters, will campaign relentlessly to change the planners' desire to wreck northern Devon with industrialisation and for the Local Plan to include policy that NO areas are suitable for wind energy development.


MAPS (external and open in new windows/tabs)
CPRE Devon Devon | Energy | Protecting Devon & Planning Applications
South Hams Renewable Energy Apps
Torridge Wind Turbine Map


All this is at the personal cost of all energy users, many of whom are being dragged into fuel poverty.

Rogues Gallery

Below: Shadow fkicker from Galsworthy Farm turbine.

Content on this page requires a newer version of Adobe Flash Player.

Get Adobe Flash player


The True Cost of our Wind
"Not only are they a blight on the landscape, they are the most expensive, inefficient and unreliable form of energy.
Many people are struggling to pay their energy bills and the dash for wind energy unnecessarily adds a considerable amount on to everyone’s bills in order to line the pockets of rich landowners.
It is Robin Hood in reverse — taking money from the poorest in order to line the pockets of the richest.
"
Philip Davies MP, Sunday Post, 04/05/2014


Who needs wind?
"TURBINE NUMBER 4 FOR OTTER POWER 13 MARCH 2014
It took just 4 hours to install turbine number 4 at Wortham Farm for Otter Power.
Beautiful weather and no wind facilitated the installation."